Where is venue considered proper when multiple defendants reside in different states?

To determine where venue is considered proper when multiple defendants reside in different states, it's essential to refer to the federal venue statute outlined in 28 U.S.C. § 1391. In such cases, venue is generally deemed proper in any district where a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred.

Choosing the district where the cause of action occurred allows for a logical nexus between the legal action and the location. This ensures that the trial is held in a forum that is convenient regarding the events leading to the dispute, reflecting the interests of justice and the efficiency of the legal process.

Options referring to other districts can be misleading as they may not establish the necessary connection to the case itself. For example, while a district in which a defendant resides or where the plaintiff resides may be appropriate in handling specific circumstances, it is not universally applicable to all claims involving multiple defendants from different states. Thus, focusing on the location of where the cause of action occurred ensures that the venue aligns with the substantive events of the case.